West River Road Resident Gives Her Side of Bike Path Story

Bonnie Fitzgerald

Share with:

FacebookTwitterGoogleTumblrLinkedInRedditPinterestEmail this pagePrint this page


Bonnie Fitzgerald
Bonnie Fitzgerald

Invites Public to “Come and Enjoy” the Glorious Eight Miles of West River

By Bonnie Fitzgerald

West River Rd. Resident

Grand Island NY — In connection with the debate raging about the proposed West River Parkway bike path, we believe that the recent article entitled “The Great Nimby” was written in poor taste, biased, one-sided and unequivocally not true.  Unfortunately, it has incited anger and hatred toward us, and we would like to tell you our side of the story.

The residents of West River are kind, generous, hardworking people who are by no means rich or wealthy. We take great pride in where we live and are the true groundskeepers of West River. That special area of Grand Island looks as beautiful as it does only because of us. After a long week of work and running the kids to various activities, we clean our houses, trim the bushes, pull the weeds, wash the windows and mow our lawns. Once we are done with all of our own household chores, we cross the street to mow the land that is supposedly being maintained by New York State. If we didn’t do this, the grass would be waist high nearly all summer, and filled with rodents and snakes.  A number of us also take out the vegetation permits in spring and fall that allow us to trim trees and clear the brush by the river’s edge. In the spring, many West River homeowners walk along the shore to clean up the garbage that appears after a long winter. Our tax dollars are supposed to go toward the maintenance of this area, but we have been told by the NYS Office of Parks that its budget permits only TWO grass cuttings a year. But we don’t complain; we just keep working to maintain its beauty for all to enjoy.

Apparently there is a gross misconception that this area is closed off to anyone but West River residents. That is simply not true.  It is a shame more Islanders don’t come and enjoy the beauty and wonder West River offers. It seems to be that Grand Island residents aren’t the only ones who embrace this area, because those of us who live on West River see many other people from all over the world who do come to enjoy its splendor. A great number of “Dip & Dive” scuba divers enjoy our river every weekend, as well as kayakers, fishermen, duck hunters, snowmobile riders, novice & street racer bicyclists, cross country skiers, horseback riders, teenagers with dirt bikes and quads, dog walkers, joggers and bird watchers, just to name a few.

Several years ago Grand Island’s then-Supervisor Mary Cooke applied for grant money from the Greenway Commission. Many months later they met with homeowners of West River to discuss the proposed plan to put a bike path along the river’s edge. At no point did we say “no” to the proposed bike path. We did, however, ask a few important questions. Who is going to maintain this bike path? Is there enough money left after all the consulting fees to finish the project are taken out? And what will happen to this bike path project if the funds run out before it is finished? The Greenway Commission and State Parks told us that “the bike path will end when the money runs out!” Our reaction was one of complete disbelief.  They said if the money runs out, even if unfinished, we will have a bike path to nowhere. Most Islanders are unaware of this because they have not attended the meetings, and apparently it is easier for them to point fingers at us and call us names instead of looking into the details of the situation.

If this goes through, our greatest fear is that we will end up like the so-called “world-class bike path” in Niagara Falls. The Robert Moses Parkway (running from the Niagara Falls State Park along the Niagara Gorge past Whirlpool State Park to Devil’s Hole State Park) is a deserted wasteland. It is overgrown and you can’t even see the beautiful gorge that faces Canada. Go any day of the week, at any time of day, and most likely no one is using it.

Thankfully, we do have another option called “Share the Road.” Cities and towns across America have already embraced this concept and it could work beautifully here. We think it would make both sides of this very heated topic very happy. Weekday commuters would still be able to use the road as usual on Monday through Friday, and then it would “close” for the weekend.  It would be open on weekend days from 7 am on Saturday to 7 pm on Sunday only for pedestrian and bicycle use in addition to other special events. There would be no extra burden on taxpayers; the only cost would be for eight barriers and a few posted signs. In addition, there would be plenty of money left to finish the bike path that ends at Bedell Road. That bike path could be placed parallel to the power lines that run through the more heavily populated part of the Island, and would be more accessible to all who wish to use it.

Thank you for reading this to the end, and we hope you found it informative.  As always, we welcome all of you to this beautiful eight-mile stretch of Grand Island and the Niagara River; please come and enjoy!

'Share the Road' proposal of some West River Road homeowners offers a plan that would keep the West River Parkway open to motorists on weekdays and close the Parkway on weekends to motorists for the use of bikers and hikers.
“Share the Road” proposal of some West River Road homeowners offers a plan that would keep the West River Parkway open to motorists on weekdays and close the Parkway on weekends to motorists for the use of bikers and hikers.
Amid questions as to how well the state would maintain the state-owned land along the eight mile stretch of West River in Grand Island, West River Road residents say they maintain the land by mowing grass, clearing unsightly brush and enhancing the views of the West River. Above is how the state maintains the land, according to Bonnie Fitzgerald, a resident.
Amid questions as to how well the state would maintain the state-owned land along the eight mile stretch of West River in Grand Island, West River Road residents say they maintain the land by mowing grass, clearing unsightly brush and enhancing the views of the West River. Above is how the state maintains the land, according to Bonnie Fitzgerald, a resident.

bonnie5

Above: how some homeowners along West River Road maintain the state-owned land along the West River.
Above: how some homeowners along West River Road maintain the state-owned land along the West River.

Share with:

FacebookTwitterGoogleTumblrLinkedInRedditPinterestEmail this pagePrint this page


7 Comments

  1. I looked into this. She doesn’t even have a permit nor anything approved by the Corps of Engineers.

  2. Leave it alone. I’m sure there are plenty of other ways to use thd federal grant money that the politicians are afraid of losing if they don’t spend it.

  3. So, like many other things done so well in New York State, someone got an idea of a bike path along the river from Buffalo to Niagara Falls. With no real thoughts or plans politicians and departments of New York State are justifying their jobs and writing checks that the tax payers are funding.
    Just another failed project funded without a thought.

  4. Then why do some residents have “private property signs”? In my eyes that’s the same as ” No Trespassing”.

  5. I lived in Niagara Falls growing up and we always used various places along the West River. There were no pull off points, so we parked on River Rd. and walked across the parkway. We never had a problem with home owners or crossing the parkway. If my mind serves me, there is enough room to build a bike path between the parkway and the river. We used to fish the West River as well. We would either motor around from LaSalle or launch our boat in Buckhorn Island Park opposite Navy Island. We always enjoyed going to Grand Island.

  6. Hey Anonymous, we do have permits. Feel free to stop by and we will show them to you. It sure is brave and big of you to tell lies when you’re not brave enough to leave your name!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*