Niagara Falls
THE
NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER
LOCAL NEWS  •  LOCAL VOICES  •  LOCAL MATTERS

“Independence Day: Resurgence” May Succeed Without the Critics this Summer

M
Mike Hudson · June 23, 2016
“Independence Day: Resurgence” May Succeed  Without the Critics this Summer
SharefXin✉

For whatever reason, 20th Century Fox has decided to launch its’ entry into the summer blockbuster sweepstakes – “Independence Day: Resurgence” – without screening it for critics in advance and with a mostly online and in-theater promotional campaign that that has been unimpressive, to say the least.

That’s usually a very bad sign.

It’s been 20 years since the original “Independence Day” largely transformed the way we look at summer action adventure sci-fi movies, and the intervening decades have not been particularly kind to the stars. Jeff Goldblum, who was edgy and funny and off the wall in the original, now looks as old as his father, played by Judd Hirsch, who remarkably made it back for the sequel.

A huge, gaping hole has been left by the refusal of Goldblum’s co-star in the original, Will Smith, to do the sequel. Roland Emmerich, who directed both films, told the London Daily Mirror that he felt “half hearted” about the new movie because of Smith’s refusal.

“That’s the point where I thought, let’s not do this movie,” he said. “Friends said I should carry on, that the ideas were really great, but I carried on in a half-hearted way.”

But there was a lot of money to be made. Fox had budgeted $200 million for the sequel, and there are easier things to walk away from. Emmerich persevered, rewriting the script to feature an army of orphans who lost their parents in the original alien invasion depicted in the first move.

The battle to save the planet from the alien invaders proceeds apace.

As with Goldblum, the 20-years that have passed have not been particularly kind to Emmerich, who directed a string of turkeys including “10,000 BC,” “2012” and “White House Down.”

So we’re left with the biggest star of the ensemble cast refusing to do the picture, a half hearted director, a last minute script rewrite and $200 million of Rupert Murdoch’s money.

Did I hear somebody say, “Hooray for Hollywood”?

If the movie was good, delivering the kind of action, adventure and laughs that the first one did, Fox would want everyone to know about it. The studio would have screened it last week, and Goldblum, Emmerich and other cast members would be making the talk show rounds relentlessly to pump it up.

They’re not, and while the movie may make back what was spent on it – both the Johnny Depp atrocity “Alice Through the Looking Glass” and the Ellen DeGeneres cartoon “Finding Dory” have managed it – chances are that opening weekend audiences will be disappointed.

SharefXin✉

Comments (0)

Leave a comment

More From Niagara Falls Reporter

Before Tuesday: Why Nate McMurray Should Win the 145th Assembly
Niagara Falls

Before Tuesday: Why Nate McMurray Should Win the 145th Assembly

By Frank Parlato · November 2, 2026

An opinion argument that Nate McMurray, a Democrat and former Grand Island supervisor, should beat Republican Becky Wydysh for the 145th Assembly seat, citing his record, his rapid response to families living near radioactive land, and the leverage that comes from sitting in the Assembly majority. The piece also scruti

Ryan Flynn Jailed Again as Cousin John Flynn Runs Unopposed
Investigative

Ryan Flynn Jailed Again as Cousin John Flynn Runs Unopposed

By Frank Parlato · November 2, 2026

Ryan Flynn, 32, who has accused his cousin, former Erie County DA John Flynn, of child sexual abuse, is jailed on a misdemeanor charge as John Flynn runs unopposed for Town of Tonawanda supervisor. John Flynn has not been charged, and Ryan Flynn's allegations remain unproven.