Niagara Falls
THE
NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER
LOCAL NEWS  •  LOCAL VOICES  •  LOCAL MATTERS

Department of 'Justice': The 97.7% Guilty Plea Machine

F
Frank Parlato · November 19, 2026
DOJ
SharefXin✉

Someday a historian will sit down with the records of the United States Department of Justice. The first thing that historian will notice is the name.

Most government agencies are named for what they handle. Agriculture handles farms. Commerce handles business. Treasury handles money. Only one department is named for a virtue. It does not call itself the Department of Prosecution or the Department of Prisons. It calls itself the Department of Justice.

That name is a promise. History will grade the department on whether it kept it.

IT STARTED AS A RESCUE

The irony goes back to the beginning. When the Department of Justice began operating on July 1, 1870, its first leader, Attorney General Amos Akerman, confronted the Ku Klux Klan. During his 18-month tenure, the department made protecting Black voting rights against organized racial terror a priority.

Under Akerman, federal prosecutors brought cases against Ku Klux Klan members, and hundreds fled Southern states to escape prosecution.

Congress created the department to handle the government's lawsuits. Akerman found something more important for it to do.

It protected ordinary people from organized terror, including violence carried out with the help of local officials. At its best, it stood between the weak and the powerful.

Today, the department that once fought abuses of power wields enormous power of its own. When it abuses that power, it is rarely held to account.

THE TRIAL IS ALMOST EXTINCT

The Constitution promises every accused person a trial by jury. The Department of Justice has made that promise nearly worthless.

According to the U.S. Sentencing Commission, 66,662 individuals were sentenced in federal court in fiscal 2025. Of those, 65,099, or 97.7 percent, pleaded guilty. The remaining 1,563, or 2.3 percent, were sentenced after trials.

Those figures exclude defendants who were acquitted or whose cases were dismissed. Even when all federal defendants are counted, trials remain rare.

According to Pew Research, 89.5 percent of federal defendants pleaded guilty in fiscal 2022, while 8.2 percent had their cases dismissed. Of 71,954 defendants, only 290 went to trial and were acquitted.

One in 250.

THE TRIAL PENALTY

That isn't proof that 97 out of 100 people were guilty as charged. It's proof the government's case almost never gets tested. A big reason, defense lawyers say, is the trial penalty.

They actually call it a penalty. For asking for a trial.

Prosecutors can stack charges until a defendant faces decades in prison if he goes to trial and loses.

Then they offer a deal. Plead guilty, and the sentence may be much shorter. The defendant is free to choose. That's what makes it a choice.

The few who do fight rarely win. In 2022, about five of every six federal defendants who went to trial were convicted.

In the same year, more than three times as many federal defendants had their cases dismissed as went to trial. Yet a dismissal doesn't make a defendant whole. It does not return the months he may have spent in jail, repay his legal fees, give back the work he lost, or repair a reputation damaged by prosecution.

Next: You have the right to a trial. Good luck with that.

doj


SharefXin✉

Comments (0)

Leave a comment

More From Niagara Falls Reporter