Niagara Falls
THE
NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER
LOCAL NEWS  •  LOCAL VOICES  •  LOCAL MATTERS

Accused dog abuser now target of ironic internet abuse himself

M
Mike Hudson · July 14, 2017
Accused dog abuser now target  of ironic internet abuse himself
SharefXin✉
The online outrage directed against Timothy Neff, who is facing felony animal cruelty charges in connection with the starvation of a pit bull mix named Precious, continues unabated.
He was arrested on June 29 by Niagara Falls city policeman Dave Bowers, an outdoorsman with a love of animals. In addition to being emaciated, the dog was also suffering with internal parasites and fleas.
Niagara County SPCA photo of Precious, a pit bull mix, who was allegedly starved nearly to death by Niagara Falls resident Timothy Neff over a period of months.
Niagara County SPCA photo of Precious, a pit bull mix, who was allegedly starved nearly to death by Niagara Falls resident Timothy Neff over a period of months.
The suspect told Bowers he had given the dog to some people in West Seneca four months ago and was recently contacted by a friend who said the dog was in poor condition. The friend then brought him the dog, he said.
Neff, who looks as though he hasn’t missed too many meals himself, advertises himself as a “home improvement handyman” and landscaper. The 20th Street resident is also reported to own rental property in Lockport.
In the wake of the online firestorm, Neff, 31, shut down his Facebook account, but not before a number of sharp eyed dog lovers managed to get his phone number from various internet advertisements. The number, 716-698-6075, was widely circulated, and many called to tell him what they thought about his treatment of animals.
They were answered with a glib voicemail message.
“Yes, I’m the guy who abused his dog,” it said. “Leave me a message.”
The heavyset Timothy Neff, 31, doesn't look like he's missed many meals. Did he eat the dog food?
The heavyset Timothy Neff, 31, doesn’t look like he’s missed many meals. Did he eat the dog food?
At least one humanitarian, Lisa Stewart-Graff, said she taped the message and made it available to authorities.
“Got his message on tape,” she posted. “Will go to SPCA tomorrow.”
In New York State, felony aggravated cruelty carries a maximum penalty of two years in prison, and more than 100 local Facebook commentators have called upon the criminal justice system to deliver all that and worse.
The posts were so fever pitched that Andrea Galyn, administrator of the popular Niagara Falls Uncensored web page, felt compelled to warn that further death threats directed against Neff would not be tolerated.
Many others, however, said they would adopt the dog and give her a permanent and loving home.
Two weeks ago, Jay Kenneth of Rochester Road in Royalton, who was charged in April with felony aggravated animal cruelty when a disturbing video surfaced of him beating his dog Spike appeared, plead guilty to attempted aggravated animal cruelty and was sentenced to 60 days of incarceration, placement on Niagara County’s Animal Abuse Registry and court fines. Ownership of Spike was awarded to the Niagara SPCA.
SharefXin✉

Comments (0)

Leave a comment

More From Niagara Falls Reporter

Ryan Flynn Jailed Again as Cousin John Flynn Runs Unopposed
Investigative

Ryan Flynn Jailed Again as Cousin John Flynn Runs Unopposed

By Frank Parlato · November 2, 2026

Ryan Flynn, 32, who has accused his cousin, former Erie County DA John Flynn, of child sexual abuse, is jailed on a misdemeanor charge as John Flynn runs unopposed for Town of Tonawanda supervisor. John Flynn has not been charged, and Ryan Flynn's allegations remain unproven.

McMurray: From the Erie Canal to Seoul, and Now to Albany
Niagara Falls

McMurray: From the Erie Canal to Seoul, and Now to Albany

By Frank Parlato · October 28, 2026

Democratic 145th Assembly District candidate Nate McMurray lost his father at 4, was raised in poverty in North Tonawanda, and went on to study and work in Seoul and Beijing before joining Samsung and later Delaware North. Now he faces Republican Becky Wydysh in next Tuesday's election.