Niagara Falls
THE
NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER
LOCAL NEWS  •  LOCAL VOICES  •  LOCAL MATTERS

Man Overcharged on Garbage Fee – City Refuses to Refund ** Update **

R
Reporter Staff · March 16, 2023
Man Overcharged on Garbage Fee – City Refuses to Refund ** Update **
SharefXin✉

Editor’s note: This individual received a full refund on Friday, March 17.

************************************************************************

A Niagara Falls man, finding himself enmeshed in a Kafkaesque bureaucratic nightmare at the hands of Niagara Falls City government, has reached out to the Reporter in an attempt to rectify a situation which never should have happened in the first place.

Last week we received the following cry for help on our Facebook page:

“I discovered I was being overcharged for city refuse fees. I’ve only ever had 1 garbage can, but I learned in January that I was being charged for 2. I contacted DPW (the city’s Department of Public Works) on several occasions. I was directed to a Roseanne, but she just happened to not be available during calls. I eventually asked for (Public Works Director) John Kinney by name when she finally announced herself, and she told me that she had reviewed my account and claimed it was being expedited to the City Controller.

“I’ve called about my money for more than 4 weeks now. Supposedly my check for over $450 was mailed out last Wednesday. Here I sit a week later and alas, no check.

“I wonder how many other people are unaware of being overcharged.

“If we didn’t pay, the city would have imposed a penalty and ultimately it goes against property taxes. They aren’t paying me interest for keeping my money, but they’re collecting interest.

“There is no paperwork within the city with my name signing for 2. They state the issue has been corrected and this year my billing will be correct, but I can send you call log screen shots showing how many times I called them.

“This is absolute bs and I would be getting harassed and penalized by the city had I refused to pay, but let them f up…

“I have to wait on them to do this, then that, but yet here we are almost a month after confirming THEIR error and I’m still the one left holding the bag…”

SharefXin✉

Comments (0)

Leave a comment

More From Niagara Falls Reporter

Before Tuesday: Why Nate McMurray Should Win the 145th Assembly
Niagara Falls

Before Tuesday: Why Nate McMurray Should Win the 145th Assembly

By Frank Parlato · November 2, 2026

An opinion argument that Nate McMurray, a Democrat and former Grand Island supervisor, should beat Republican Becky Wydysh for the 145th Assembly seat, citing his record, his rapid response to families living near radioactive land, and the leverage that comes from sitting in the Assembly majority. The piece also scruti

Ryan Flynn Jailed Again as Cousin John Flynn Runs Unopposed
Investigative

Ryan Flynn Jailed Again as Cousin John Flynn Runs Unopposed

By Frank Parlato · November 2, 2026

Ryan Flynn, 32, who has accused his cousin, former Erie County DA John Flynn, of child sexual abuse, is jailed on a misdemeanor charge as John Flynn runs unopposed for Town of Tonawanda supervisor. John Flynn has not been charged, and Ryan Flynn's allegations remain unproven.