Niagara Falls
THE
NIAGARA FALLS REPORTER
LOCAL NEWS  •  LOCAL VOICES  •  LOCAL MATTERS

Restaurant Review: Three Over Restaurant & Bar

S
Staff · August 8, 2018
Restaurant Review: Three Over Restaurant & Bar
SharefXin✉

Please click the link below to subscribe to a FREE PDF version of each print edition of the Niagara Reporter

http://eepurl.com/dnsYM9

 

 

 

By: Jamie DePetris

Food Expert/Critic

Three Over Restaurant, located at the Hyde Park Golf Course on Porter Road, is by no means a new restaurant/bar for me. I have dined and have been at the bar here several times.

This place is usually packed with locals from morning til’ night. Breakfast, lunch, drinks (like what I did there? Ha!) and dinner, there is most definitely something for everyone.

Some people come to eat and other to enjoy awesome company and have a few beers. I do all of the above.

Our meal began with Quesadilla’s cooked perfectly crisp outside and gooey inside. I’m not sure why this simple dish could taste so darn good, but it did!

This could have been a meal itself, but of course I opted for more! I tried Pat’s creation, “the peanut butter bacon burger.”

Your first thought was also mine, and yes it does look as crazy as you’re picturing!

 

 

The handmade burger that might just be the juiciest thing I have ever had in my life. The bacon and peanut butter together is absolutely decadent.

You may think, “ewwww peanut butter on a burger,” but you better get that thought right out of your head because this burger will be your favorite forever.

I even went home and tried to replicate it myself. There’s a reason I’m a food critic and not a chef though because my daughter told me I should stick to my day job.

Gee, thanks Alyssa.

The fries that come with it were very good as well but, to be honest, I was too focused on my burger to think about fries.

I also managed to fit in trying the French onion soup which was superb. The broth was rich and it had just the right amount of melted cheese is mouthwatering and outstanding.

In the past I have had several meals here. A favorite? The fish fry.

 

 

For me this place is not just about the fantastic food and the thought that goes into it, but about the kindness and compassion I’ve seen each and every time I walk in here.

This place is another hidden gem that I’m sure most of you don’t know about.

Give it and try and make sure to tell them Jamie sent you!

SharefXin✉

Comments (0)

Leave a comment

More From Niagara Falls Reporter

Before Tuesday: Why Nate McMurray Should Win the 145th Assembly
Niagara Falls

Before Tuesday: Why Nate McMurray Should Win the 145th Assembly

By Frank Parlato · November 2, 2026

An opinion argument that Nate McMurray, a Democrat and former Grand Island supervisor, should beat Republican Becky Wydysh for the 145th Assembly seat, citing his record, his rapid response to families living near radioactive land, and the leverage that comes from sitting in the Assembly majority. The piece also scruti

Ryan Flynn Jailed Again as Cousin John Flynn Runs Unopposed
Investigative

Ryan Flynn Jailed Again as Cousin John Flynn Runs Unopposed

By Frank Parlato · November 2, 2026

Ryan Flynn, 32, who has accused his cousin, former Erie County DA John Flynn, of child sexual abuse, is jailed on a misdemeanor charge as John Flynn runs unopposed for Town of Tonawanda supervisor. John Flynn has not been charged, and Ryan Flynn's allegations remain unproven.